Username
Password
ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
By Gaurang December 17 2007
The fact that the ICL was able to get off the ground was a significant achievement, considering the amount of opposition it generated from the BCCI, who saw it as a direct assault on its cricket monopoly. The BCCI tried its best to subvert, even sabotage, ICL's existence. But much to the dismay of the BCCI and delight of ordinary cricket fans their efforts were mostly unsuccessful.

The ICL showed that when cricketers are put in charge of cricket the product is of a much better quality, despite limitations in the raw materials, than when bureaucrats and politicians run the show.  One of the key questions that skeptics of the ICL had posed was whether International players would be able to gel with Indian players, especially since there could have been a language and cultural barrier in the case of many of the young local players.  That fear has been proven totally unfounded.  In fact the International players have fitted in brilliantly with the local lads and as promised by Kapil Dev and Co. they have taken them under their wing and the local youngsters, and not so young Indian players alike, have benefited immensely from rubbing shoulders and sharing a locker room with the likes of Stuart Law, Chris Cairns, Marvan Atapattu, Craig McMillan, Inzamam-ul-Haq and Brian Lara, etc.

 

This aspect of the ICL is very heartening and in complete contrast to the Indian Premier League (IPL), that the BCCI is floating.  The IPL has to date only announced the signing up of  "Stars”, that too international ones.  No Indian youngster has been signed up by the IPL.   

 

In contrast not only has ICL signed up over a hundred young players it has given youngsters like Ali Murtaza of the Delhi Jets, or forgotten, but experienced domestic performers like Kiran Powar, brother of Ramesh, of Mumbai Champs and Rajagopal Sathish of the Chennai Superstars a shot at not just financial security, but a bit of fame, and the chance to display their skills to the whole world.    

 

By bringing in professionalism in the running of cricket in India, ICL has already raised the bar several notches, and the BCCI are being pushed to improve their ways of operating as well.  The Chennai Superstars under impressive Australia trio of Stuart Law, Ian Harvey and Coach Michael Bevan were deserving winners of the inaugural ICL T20 tournament, and already four more events have been planned for 2008. 

 

The ultimate beneficiary of this competition will undoubtedly be the Indian fan, who despite providing huge amounts of money to the BCCI, as well as the ICC, has often received the shoddiest of treatment from these entities.   If Indian fans are no longer treated like shoppers at a government ration shop, and instead treated more like well-heeled  patrons at a fancy boutique, then the ICL will have done its job. 

 

Now the ball is in BCCI’s court and it is high time it rescinds the ban on young Indian players who decided to play in the ICL.  That BCCI were willing to rescind the ban on   ICL’s foreign stars, such as Brian Lara, and Inzamam ul Haq,  shows that they have no principled basis for their stand, which is nothing more than a thinly disguised lock-out of the young Indian cricketers whose labor they depend on for their fat paychecks.  If the BCCI stopped acting like the proverbial dog in the manger and recognized that the ICL is simply helping to grow the pie of Indian cricket, it would welcome rather than fight the ICL tooth and nail while trying to hog the entire pie for itself.

 

Bookmark or share this story with:

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListNew TopicSearchLog In
Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: kappax (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:18:02:15:20

well said...

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: anu_D (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:18:04:45:24

It's a statement that reminds me of the American declaration...."we won the war on terror in Afganistan"

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:18:06:52:07

Btw, does anyone have a package of some of the fielding by Indian youngsters in the ICL tourney...it was AMAZING...

The run out of Ian Harvey by Sarabjeet Singh the Chandigarh wicket keeper was one of the BEST pieces of fielding I have seen...and I have been watching cricket since the 1970s...

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Anil (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:18:14:31:14

Great to see the success of ICL.

Even without the ingredient of "nationalism" that makes international sport a big draw for any country, they have shown how to run the game.

They have also clearly demonstrated that they are more qualified to run Indian cricket than the corrupt and political BCCI.

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:19:20:21:52

BCCI quietly is sending THIRTY...yes you got it...THIRTY officials to Australia for JUNKETS during the INdian tour down under...


One gets the idea of the priority of the BCCI and ICL when you see this sort of thing..

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:23:18:05:56

I would like to hear a bit more abut ICL's next steps...though they may purposely being laying low... to keep out of the cross hairs of the BCCI..

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: anu_D (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:05:29:41

I would like to see outside of our ICF and Zee...if there are any published opinions / reviews/ comments / statements / declarations about the success or even impending sucess of ICL ?????



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007:12:24:05:31:20 by anu_D.

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: kappax (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:05:36:50

as if thats gonna chance ur mind & its perceptions smiling smiley

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: anu_D (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:05:39:30

^ yes multiple, neutral opinions impact and do modify my perspective if presented rationally

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:06:29:47

Then google away sister...

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:06:44:51

Latest Impact of ICL...


New Zealand look to counter ICL threat

Cricinfo staff

December 23, 2007



Player earnings could increase as New Zealand Cricket focus on retaining top players © Getty Images




Radical measures could be taken to prevent their players from signing lucrative contracts with the Indian Cricket League (ICL) and turning their backs on their country, Justin Vaughan, New Zealand Cricket's chief executive, has said. These measures include increasing the number of centrally contracted players to 25 as well as increasing the value of player retainers.

The inaugural edition of the ICL included retired players from New Zealand like Nathan Astle, Chris Cairns, Craig McMillan and Chris Harris. While New Zealand lost just two current players to the league - Daryll Tuffey and Hamish Marshall - Vaughan fears that the number could increase, with the ICL organisers announcing plans for four new tournaments next season and also increasing the number of teams from six to eight. ICL-contracted players are allowed to play domestic cricket in New Zealand but are not eligible for selection for national or A teams.

"We have a shallow player pool and we can't afford to lose players," Vaughan told the New Zealand's Herald on Sunday. "But we are keeping an eye on it and maybe there are things that we can look at in the structure of our contracts."

The Indian board has also lured New Zealand's premier players like Stephen Fleming, Daniel Vettori, Brendon McCullum, Jacob Oram and Scott Styris, to sign up for its officially-sanctioned, cash-rich Indian Premier League (IPL), set to commence in April next year. While these players have agreed to honour their country ahead of their franchise teams and that the IPL is not viewed as a threat unlike the ICL, Vaughan felt that the board will have to ensure they aren't tempted by the financial incentives being offered by the BCCI to participate.

"The process of picking these players is the BCCI's business and we've put forward our best players for consideration and they choose who they want," Vaughan said.

Vaughan said the matter was being discussed with the New Zealand Cricket Players' Association to work out a new structure for the contracts. Retaining elite players would, in all probability, be given more importance than increasing the pool of untried contracted players.

"We don't know how we might structure that but we will be working very closely with the [New Zealand] Players' Association on this one," Vaughan said. "We are starting to talk to Heath Mills, [Players' Association head] about what might be possible. It's this balance - yes we'd like to lock up as many players as possible but, you can either pay fewer people more or more people basically what they're getting now."

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:06:46:16

The tournament was a success...

Here is CI's take on it..

Nagraj Gollapudi

December 17, 2007



The new rock n'roll: the Chennai Superstars do a victory lap after their win © Cricinfo Ltd



From the time the Indian Cricket League was conceived, the question on everyone's lips was: will it grow or will it be stillborn? If one takes popularity as the yardstick, the grand finale on Sunday evening at the packed Tau Devi Lal Stadium would have put to rest all speculation. The stadium, which is about equidistant from both the Sector 16 ground in Chandigarh and the Punjab Cricket Association's stadium in Mohali, can normally accommodate around 6000, but that figure swelled to 10,000 for the final, with people thronging the railings of various stands, and packing themselves into the grass banks that ring the ground outside.

Subhash Chandra, the head of the Zee group, the league's backers, and Kapil Dev declared the inaugural edition a success as they unveiled plans for the future, but their smiling faces hid uncertainty. For the moment the matter of whether the public would recognise the ICL had been dispelled, but one question remains: did those people throng to the ground to witness a sporting spectacle, or was it the other delights on offer that sucked them in?

The verdict from Panchkula has been no different to those from other parts of the world when it comes to the carnival atmosphere of Twenty20. "Entertainment" was the most popular response if you asked young and old on Sunday for the reason for their attendance at the final. For his part, Kapil has no problems with that. "Sport to me is entertainment and I'll let the public decide what is good for them," he said. Then, in what seemed like an aside, but was delivered in seriousness, he added, "If the crowd would like horse-jumping or a dog show, we'll get them."

Of course, definitions of entertainment vary. For die-hard cricket fans the sight of Chris Cairns blasting sixes over the stands was a dream come true. For others it was the glitter, the dancing girls, the music. Young girls, not quite impressed with the ICL's line-up of players, came in to watch the final nevertheless, to experience something different. For them it was all about the festive spirit.

Shrieks, whistles and horns swept the stadium every time a performer stepped on to the stage. Tanushree Dutta, a former Miss India, now a Bollywood starlet, had the crowd's eyeballs glued to the big screen and stage during the final. On the preceding days, Bollywood beauties Kareena Kapoor, Malaika Arora Khan, and Yana Gupta, and popular singers Kailash Kher and Sukhwinder had performed before completely full to near-vacant stands.

If anything can grapple with the might of cricket in India, it is Bollywood. No wonder, then, that some in the BCCI took umbrage recently at Shahrukh Khan's turning up at Twenty20 games and ODIs, in what they saw as an attempt to promote his films using the cricket. The ICL, backed by Chandra's clout in Bollywood, brought the cast of the forthcoming Sunday - Ajay Devgan, Irrfan Khan, and Ayesha Takia - in for the final. Those three together may not have been able to match the star value of Khan, the reigning emperor of the Hindi movie industry, but Chandra understood that something was better than nothing.

The other stars who stole the show were the cheerleaders, referred to here as "dancing girls", none of them Indian. At the end of the evening, amid the Chennai Superstars' victory celebrations, one bunch of the girls happened to pass through the ground, moving to the other end. The crowd, which had been allowed inside the ring to mingle with the players, turned eagerly to the young women as they walked nervously past, in single file. Fortunately, there were bouncers on hand to see the girls across safe. The atmosphere had something of a college festival or a carnival about it.

It wasn't just the young who had been lured by the glitter and the razzmatazz. Families formed a big chunk of the crowd that braved the numbing cold to watch the Superstars put it across the Chandigarh Lions for the million-dollar prize.




"Sport to me is entertainment and I'll let the public decide what is good for them. If the crowd would like horse-jumping or a dog show, we'll get them"
Kapil Dev









Among the incentives was the fairly priced tickets. Engineering student Vikas Dhiman, a 21-year-old Panchkula native, got a free ticket along with the one he bought for Rs 100. On weekends, for Rs 150 one could watch two games. There were no restrictions on bringing bottles of water or other beverages into the stands. The usual red tape that exists at a regular cricket stadium in India was absent, and the crowd management was smooth, all of which served to make the spectator experience that much more comfortable.

Disappointingly for the organisers, though, by and large, except on the opening and closing days, the turnouts were sparse. Even if a fair number of the league games were played over weekends, and there were stars like Brian Lara, Inzamam-ul-Haq and Chris Cairns on view, the masses didn't pour in. Reportedly, most of those who did turn up were pass-holders from the Haryana Urban Development Authority, which rented the ground to the ICL, and friends and relatives of the various sponsors and organisers.

There may have been a yawning gap between what was on offer in Panchkula and the international Twenty20 experience, but those who did turn up seemed to enjoy themselves. Will they be back for another edition? Chances are, they will. As long as the entertainment is dished out, the actual cricket will not matter much. The curtains have just gone up on the ICL show.

Nagraj Gollapudi is an assistant editor at Cricinfo

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Max (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:06:56:42

ICL did much better than expected. Some posters here said it wouldn't even take off. Now that they have been proved wrong, they are resorting to more silly speculations.

We at Indian Cricket Fever wish ICL more success in the future and will continue to support them.

_________________

India's Test record against Australia over last 12 years:

Played 22, Won 8, Lost 10, Drawn 4

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Max (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:06:59:18

Btw, Anil, Birbal, I have an article on the positives and negatives of ICL's inaugral tournament. Will send it out to you soon.

_________________

India's Test record against Australia over last 12 years:

Played 22, Won 8, Lost 10, Drawn 4

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:07:00:33

Cool Max... send it over and I can edit/post it...

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: anu_D (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:07:57:27

==>> A bunch of jat villagers in a sleepy hamlet suddenly given free tickets to oogle / lecher/ lascivate over scantily clad women....and even attemtping to get physically close...prevented by the bouncers......is NOT SUCCESS for cricket.

You could through such sex-items in front of perverse conservative villagers and play some school cricket in the background...they will still come.
Cricket was incidental to the whole thing.




Shrieks, whistles and horns swept the stadium every time a performer stepped on to the stage. Tanushree Dutta, a former Miss India, now a Bollywood starlet, had the crowd's eyeballs glued to the big screen and stage during the final. On the preceding days, Bollywood beauties Kareena Kapoor, Malaika Arora Khan, and Yana Gupta

The other stars who stole the show were the cheerleaders, referred to here as "dancing girls", none of them Indian. At the end of the evening, amid the Chennai Superstars' victory celebrations, one bunch of the girls happened to pass through the ground, moving to the other end. The crowd, which had been allowed inside the ring to mingle with the players, turned eagerly to the young women as they walked nervously past, in single file. Fortunately, there were bouncers on hand to see the girls across safe

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: anu_D (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:08:02:17

Subhash Chandra, the head of the Zee group, the league's backers, and Kapil Dev declared the inaugural edition a success


C.I reports...Chandra and Kapil declared it a success

Yeah Bush declared his war against terror in Afganistan a success...

Re: ICL Proves The Skeptics Wrong
Posted by: Max (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:14:25:37

Thanks Birbal, I just emailed you the article.

_________________

India's Test record against Australia over last 12 years:

Played 22, Won 8, Lost 10, Drawn 4

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net