Username
Password
ICL T20 Positives and Negatives
By Max December 24 2007
The inaugural Twenty20 Tournament of the ICL was watched by a global audience which was easily in the millions, and here are a few impressions that I, as one of those millions, formed as I watched the tournament unfold over the period of two weeks.

Positives

1. Fielding - It was nothing short of top-class from all the teams. The commitment of the younger Indian players was fantastic and they really dazzled. The diving stops on a sandy and rough outfield were breathtaking, and the throwing to hit the stumps was much more accurate than usual.  Even slow moving Inzamam ul Haq was seen dashing to collect the ball and then throwing down the stumps from side on.  All credit to these guys and also the coaches and support staff who helped with the training.

2. Umpiring - Most of the umpires were current or retired professionals from
England, with the token Indian in the form of Dr. Vaghela.  They all looked much more competent than many of the umpires in the ICC's so called Elite Panel. There were no blatant mistakes and that's more than what can be said about the umpiring in ICC's "official" matches.

3. Technology - Apart from more powers given to 3rd umpire, they also had gadgets like heart rate monitor, a very interesting sky cam that gave a birds eye view of the bowling and fielding.  Another bit of technology was for the use of the players was an exer-cycle available in the dug out, for  the in-coming batsman to warm up. These were innovative new additions and all credit to the organizers.

4. Exciting talent - Some of the young Indian players really made a mark. The likes of Sujay Tarafdar, TP Singh, Ali Murtaza, R. Sathish etc showed real ability to perform at a higher level. I'm sure over the next year, the ICL will unearth many more such players.

5.  The TV coverage was excellent.  The presentation team headed by the beautiful, yet intelligent and charming Mayanti Langer, along with the legendary Tony Grieg with others such as Dean Jones, Jeff Thomson, Pat Symcox, Ayaz Memon, Rohan Gavaskar, etc. was top notch and a joy to watch and listen to.



Negatives

1. Quality of bowling was not a very high standard, though it was above general FC level. Though in mitigation one must admit that in the Twenty20 format, even the best of bowlers often become cannon fodder, just ask Shaun Pollock.  However, the ICL should make it a point to identify better quality bowlers (both domestic and overseas) while signing up new players for the next tournament.

2. The ground was not in the best shape. The organizers did their level best to bring the ground into shape, but the refusal of the various local stadia owners under threat from BCCI to lease regular grounds to the ICL means that the ICL needs to find out a way to get around this.  They may need to go to court if necessary, but in any case with some 3 months to go before the next ICL tournament, I hope the organizers focus on getting the ground to international standards.

3. I really think they should do away with the dances and performances. Cheerleaders and background music (with DJ, etc) is fine, but they should stop with that. Ultimately the success of their venture depends on the quality of cricket being played. And I thought the quality was promising, definitely better than I expected for the first tournament. People will come to watch the cricket. If they want to watch some B-Grade Bollywood star performing, they will go to some live show. So instead of wasting time and money on this, the ICL organizers should focus on improving the cricket related activities.

Overall, from this tournament, I can sense that the ICL does have a future and a fairly bright one, if they play their cards properly.  However they also have immense challenges, the least of which is not the extreme hostility of the BCCI who want to wipe them out.  It is going to be a very interesting period in Indian cricket.  I for one wish them all the best for the future.

Bookmark or share this story with:

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListNew TopicSearchLog In
Re: ICL T20 Positives and Negatives
Posted by: ananthd (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:16:09:11

Max:
Agree on most points; although I thought the commentators sometimes were caught up in their own hype especially Deano.


Small edit: Its Ayaz Memon, not Menon!

Re: ICL T20 Positives and Negatives
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:16:14:24

To be fair to Max...that stuff about the commentators was added by me... though Max wrote about 90 percent of the article...

But he did not mention the commentators in his draft...

So in reality he may actually agree with you ananthd..smiling smiley

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Re: ICL T20 Positives and Negatives
Posted by: Anil (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:18:19:26

Thanks for the very nice coverage of the goings-on in ICL!

Looks like having cricketers in charge, rather than the morons as in BCCI and ICC, has made a world of difference.

Denying use of grounds is bogus, and should be challenged in court.

A huge advantage of ICL is that they are recruiting the best of the up and comers. This is unlike IPL, which refuses to recruit young Indians, and only features past greats 2 years after their retirement.

It's encouraging to see, all the best to ICL, they have started well and the future can only hold better things!

Re: ICL T20 Positives and Negatives
Posted by: Birbal (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:24:19:07:36

Anil can we get a different picture... for this ICL article...

I am huge Kapil Fan...but we need to go beyond his mug...smiling smiley

_____

ICL Ko Support Karo Yaro...

BCCI Ko Joote Chappal Maro....

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net