Username
Password
Where is the Effort?
By GoCool December 30 2007
Reams of newsprint and webspace have been sacrificed to analyze the depth of India's loss to the best test nation in the world. There have been reports of lack of preperation, forced batting order shuffles, unlucky decisions, extreme climatic conditions, negative mindsets, poor fielding and running between the wickets... anything else?

How about favoritism and politics? How could that be left out?

Bring it all out people, because this Indian team can take all the cannons fired at them right now. That is one area where their  experience really counts. Although, It won't really affect their fortunes on this Australian tour. The more flak they face, the more immune to it they will be.

That said, let us attempt to understand some ground realities: 

Man-for-man Australia is a better team than India. They have better openers, a stronger middle order, an equally strong 6 and 7 and the world's most stubborn tail. Their batting is based on attack and still more attack. Several of them click in partnerships.Hardly a defensive bone in that line-up. 

Australia 5, India 1 

And that was just the batting...let's move on to the bowling strengths:

Australia has faster bowlers, consistently more accurate bowlers, more experienced bowlers and a good test-class spinner. India has one world-class fast bowler and one legend of a legspinner.

Australia 4, India 2. 

Now fielding:

Australia has at least 9 world class fielders. India has 2? I could be off on that count and beg to be proven wrong. 

Australia 9, India 2

I must say I am  liking this little exercise of mine. The scores are adding up nicely. Very good indeed, let's go to the fitness sector and see how the teams fare: 

Australia are fitter than India. Goes without saying. I will spare the details because I don't know them. It is evident however, that the Australian physique is hardier than the Indian one and to achieve it, they have worked harder at it than the Indians. Age is just a number.

Australia 11, India 2 (being very generous here) 

Finally, my favorite yardstick of measure - Effort.

Australia put in 100% effort in all 4 sessions  of a days play. India's effort is seriously lacking in sessions when it really needs to be cranked up. Like England before them who played with complete effort only in certain sessions, The Indians are giving up when they are required to press harder. There is a serious lack of effort that is spreading like a virus in the Indian batting order. I don't know why; perhaps the reasons are similar to Milkha Singh's who missed out on a bronze at the Olympics( because in his own words, he held back to leave something in the tank for the finish). 

Whatever it is, I don't really care. I want to see effort. I saw little of that. The Indian cricketers know it to be true.  If anyone of them is reading this, I would suggest they watch a tape of a physically sick Leander Paes beating Goran Ivanisevic in 5 gut-wrenching sets during a Davis Cup game. 

On effort alone:

Australia 10, India 3

Let's add up the total scores:

Australia - 39

India - 10

Based on this little study of mine, I would conclude that it is inevitable for India to lose this series. Nothing wrong in losing to the best. Let us therefore, accept the truth and stop beating our chests on India losing. However, in the world of competitive sport, there is no greater crime than an excuse for lack of effort.

To those Indian cricketers who are holding back, I say to them, leave now and do not disgrace the country further. I would rather see more fight and less talent in this Indian line-up than a galaxy of stars who shine with past glories.

Bookmark or share this story with:

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListNew TopicSearchLog In
Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: Indian Well Wisher (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:30:10:01:41

Agree with all except man-to-man batting comparison...Our batting on paper is stronger that AUS...

However the total count will still remain someting like 40-10..as I would give AUS even higher points in efforts, attitude etc...

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: Chorazin Reto (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:30:12:51:18

I think on paper its stronger, but a player by player comparison for batters would be.

Haden - Dravid
Jaques - Jaffer
Ponting - Tendulkar
Symonds - Yuvraj
Clarke - Ganguly
Gilchrist - Dhoni
Hussey - Laxman

The issue is current form, I would take, on current form, just about every Aussie batsmen there over the Indian counterpart.

[aus.cricinfo.com]

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: Indian Well Wisher (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:30:13:13:47

^ Yeah that is the bane of Indian Cricket..The batting more often than not remains strong only on paper, the current form always drops at the slightest opportunity..

Otherwise with such bats , India would be at least be consistently no. 2 side in the world since 2000...

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: GoCool (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:30:20:02:44

Hussey, Gilchrist, Ponting, Jacques and Hayden all have test averages over 50 and superior strike rates to the Indian batters. Dravid and Sachin are the only batters from India with 50 plus average. And one of them is not in form. There goes your Paper theory. The best batting line-up was never India, it has been Australia.

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: kappax (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:30:22:37:21

Well if current form as of start of Oz tour.. then India is stronger..

but after 1st test Oz is stronger man to man..

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: Anil (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:31:02:42:50

Nice one, GoCool.

I wonder if the Rahul Dravid display counts as "effort"?

He was working hard, laboring actually.. in his mind he may have made an effort.

Yuvraj seems not to put in the effort, though.

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: Max (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:31:03:30:46

Good analysis there GoCool. However I disagree with your assessment of the bowling attacks...Indian bowlers are always underrated. But they generally do a fairly good job overseas. Even at Melbourne, they managed to restrict a rampant Aussie batting lineup to around 350 in both innings. Not exactly an easy task, especially in their own backyard. And Indian batting has the ability to do well. It's just that the team management completely screwed up the opening positions. They made the two biggest misfits to open the batting, and that resulted in complete disaster for India. There's still hope for the remaining Tests though if Kumble can realize his mistake and change the openers.

_________________

India's Test record against Australia over last 12 years:

Played 22, Won 8, Lost 10, Drawn 4

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: GoCool (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:31:03:46:51

Dravid's 'effort' was partly a labor of dissent. Mostly because he's not in form. He's not in form because I believe his feet are too wide apart when he takes his stance, Srikkanth style. Result: the crucial little foot movements have been replaced with some clumsiness. more results: Imbalance, unsure of where the off stump is, tendency to jab and playing a cover drive without his head over the ball.

Watch when he drives: because of his stance, the front foot does not go as far is it used to, to get to the pitch of the ball. Thus a drivable ball to a batsman with an erect stance becomes a good length delivery of sorts to Dravid. The Australians know this too well. See how he's nicking too many of these balls behind or gets beaten.

Experts say it was a mindset issue and he's technically fine. Nonsense. Mindset after 114 tests? I'm not buying that. The Australians love what's going on on the other camp! The little pieces of news like Yuvraj's attitude and Dravid's mindset is like a huge psychological weapon for them to use against India and tighten the screws further.

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: kappax (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:31:03:52:02

yes mindset is the problem... even after 114 tests...

this is not a one-off mindset too.. happenned before, will happen again..

but as Punter said "the beauty of technology" is such that they may have very well picked up what you said about RD...

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: GoCool (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:31:03:54:50

Well, Kappax, I agree with you in part. But this is where the big boys play. If a cricketer is not fit mentally or otherwise, he should be dropped.

Re: Where is the Effort?
Posted by: kappax (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:12:31:04:13:09

gotta be dropped if it was a mindset issue, but as I post in the Kumble column thread..

it seems to be a planning issue mainly..

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net