Username
Password
Captain's Book Reviewed - What Sport Tells Us.....

Well ritt
By Jsolo April 8 2008
Jack Solock reviews Ed Smith's new book - "What Sport Tells Us About Life". Jack is based in Wisconsin and was introduced to cricket by the internet, radio and books, including both of Ed Smith's earlier books. Jack Solock is therefore in a unique position to provide insight into our skipper's latest effort with the pen. Many thanks to Jack for this.

Before I discuss Ed Smith's new book "What Sport Tells Us About Life", I must admit to a prejudice about Ed Smith's books. I am a relatively new cricket fan. I have been following cricket for only six years after over
40 years as a baseball fanatic and long time club fast pitch softball player. As far as the literature of cricket, I educated myself on the work
of C.L.R. James, David Frith, Jack Williams, and Michael Manley. From them I got quite a bit about the history and sociology of the game.


Generally, I'm not terribly partial to books written by sportsmen. They are usually, though not always, self serving diatribes or tell alls. But I first stumbled onto Ed's first book, "Playing Hardball", because I was very interested in how a cricketer might view baseball. "Playing hardball" was an intelligent, entertaining read, which helped me learn a great deal about cricket.

 

[Editor's note: Ged reviewed  "Hardball" in 2005 when Ed Smith first joined Middlesex:

http://www.cricketnetwork.co.uk/main/s66/st64121.htm]

"On and Off the Field", Ed's second book, was an insider's diary of a professional season. Again, an intelligent and entertaining read, comparable and actually better than the first great baseball
diarist, the almost forgotten Jim Brosnan (a pitcher with many teams, but who wrote two books about his seasons with Cincinnati and St. Louis respectively). With Brosnan, it was immediately apparent that this was a writer who was also a pitcher.

[Editor's note: Ged also reviewed "On and Off" when Ed  first joined Middlesex: http://www.cricketnetwork.co.uk/main/s66/st64883.htm]


And so it is with Ed Smith. This is a writer who is also a cricketer. My prejudice is to expect excellence from Ed Smith the author before I even open the book. And "What Sport Tells Us About Life" does not disappoint.

 


First and foremost, it is entertaining, a very fast read. But it is not shallow. Second, it is thoughtful. It will, I think, help the reader to
think about sports in significantly different ways than he or she might have before reading it.


The book begins by asking "what kind of sports fan are you?" From there the reader goes on an eclectic tour of many aspects of sport. The book
ranges from a Macaulian explanation of why England won the Ashes to an interview with Nick Hornby about why he likes sport. It touches on the thin line between greatness and madness (in sport and other endeavors), a sentimental recollection of Welsh Rugby, a very interesting explanation of why there will never be another Don Bradman, and many other fascinating
topics.

 

Smith uses words well, never writing more than needs to be written to get to the point.


My favorite chapters in the book were about the amateur ideal and the importance and meaning of luck in sport. Here we find what I think is
ideal in a book, seemingly a new idea to think about almost every page. This is a book that can easily be read in a day, but you might want to take more time to allow yourself to mull over the ideas.


When you read the book, pay careful attention to the chapter on amateurism. I think there are insights into the batsman and captain here.
You may or may not agree. The theme is play well and enjoy your game.

 

I think the Captain is going to have a big year this year. If he does, I submit, I think you can read it between the lines in this book.

 

Available from all good book shops, itinerent book-sellers and of course Amazon:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/What-Sport-Tells-About-Life/dp/0670917222/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1207634071&sr=1-1 

What Sport Tells Us About Life: Bradman's Average, Zidane's Kiss and Other Sporting Lessons (Hardcover)
by Ed Smith (Author)

RRP:£14.99
Price:£8.99 & eligible for Free UK delivery on orders over £15 with Super Saver Delivery. See details and conditions
You Save:£6.00 (40%)
Availability: In stock. Dispatched from and sold by Amazon.co.uk.
 

Bookmark or share this story with:

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListNew TopicSearchLog In
Re: Captain's Book Reviewed - What Sport Tells Us.....
Posted by: Tapioca (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:04:09:14:26:23

Jbs of #cricket, I suppose. Small world !

Re: Captain's Book Reviewed - What Sport Tells Us.....
Posted by: loverboy (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:04:09:14:58:56

EH?

Re: Captain's Book Reviewed - What Sport Tells Us.....
Posted by: jsolo (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:04:09:17:18:50

One and the same! What is your moniker on #cricket?

Re: Captain's Book Reviewed - What Sport Tells Us.....
Posted by: Ged (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:04:09:20:58:26

Can someone please explain to the unitiated what "#cricket" is and where precisely it might be found?

Re: Captain's Book Reviewed - What Sport Tells Us.....
Posted by: jsolo (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:04:09:21:44:02

Hi Ged. #cricket is a "channel" on the Internet Relay Chat (IRC). #cricket was a way, for a long time, to follow ball by ball commentaries from CI, without having to be on the web. We would follow the game on #cricket, and then join in the banter on #crickettalk. It was like being at a virtual ground. They don't do CI bbbs any more, they do Cricketarchive.co.uk bbbs now. Crowds have gotten smaller, but Indian matches still draw pretty good ones. #cricket/#crickettalk is where I got much of my cricket education.

Hope this helps.

Jack

Re: Captain's Book Reviewed - What Sport Tells Us.....
Posted by: Ged (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:04:10:05:36:53

Thnaks for that, Jack.

There are whole other worlds out there - who'd 'ave thought it?

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net